When people think about “selling the business,” they usually picture one scenario. You find an outside buyer, you negotiate a price, and you hand over the keys.
That’s certainly the most common route. However, it isn’t the only one, and the right choice depends on what matters most to you.
In this post, we’ll walk through three very different ways to exit: a trade sale, an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT) and a management buyout (MBO). We’ll look at how each one works, what it does well, and where it falls short. Finally, we’ll help you decide between them.
Why Your Exit Route Matters
Many owners focus on the price and treat everything else as secondary. Price matters, of course. Yet the route you choose shapes much more than the number on the contract.
For example, it affects what happens to your staff. Clients will also feel the change, and the process may take longer than you expect. Above all, the route decides how much say you keep over the future of the business you built.
Two owners could sell businesses of identical value and walk away with very different outcomes. One might feel proud of what they handed over, while the other might regret how it turned out. Often, the difference comes down to choosing the right route at the start.
Option 1: The Trade Sale
A trade sale means selling your business to another company. Often, the buyer is a competitor or a business in a related field that wants to grow.
What a trade sale does well
- Highest price: A trade buyer can often see benefits that nobody else can offer, such as new customers, new products or cost savings. Because they capture that extra value, they’re usually willing to pay more.
- Money upfront: Many trade sales pay a large share of the price at completion, so you can make a clean financial break.
- A faster exit: Depending on the deal, you may step away relatively quickly once the sale completes.
Where a trade sale falls short
- Less say afterwards: Once the new owner takes over, they make the decisions. For instance, they might merge teams, change the brand or close an office.
- A more public process: To find a buyer, you usually need to share information with outsiders. As a result, worry can spread among staff and clients if word leaks.
- A reshaped business: The qualities that attract a trade buyer, such as overlap with their own operations, often lead them to change things.
So a trade sale suits owners who put price first and feel comfortable letting go of control once the deal is done.
Option 2: The Employee Ownership Trust (EOT)
An EOT means selling all or part of the business into a trust. The trust holds the shares on behalf of your employees, so the team owns the company collectively rather than as individuals.
What an EOT does well
- Culture and continuity: The business stays in the hands of people who already understand it. Clients keep dealing with familiar faces, and staff needn’t worry about a new owner changing everything.
- A rewarded team: Employees share in the future success of the business. Many owners find that deeply satisfying, particularly if they feel loyalty to the people who helped them succeed.
- A gradual step back: You don’t need to leave all at once. Instead, many owners stay involved for a period, then reduce their role over time.
- No public sale: You can avoid marketing the business or approaching competitors.
Where an EOT falls short
- Payment over time: The company typically pays you from its future profits, so you don’t get the full price on day one. Consequently, you carry some risk after the sale.
- A possibly lower price: Because no outside buyer is competing, the price rests on a fair valuation rather than a bidding contest.
- Steady profits needed: The company funds your payments, so it has to generate enough cash to cover them while still running well.
- Strict rules: The trust must follow specific legal requirements, and the tax position has changed recently. For that reason, proper advice matters here.
Overall, an EOT is a good fit for owners who care deeply about continuity and culture, and who have a strong team ready to keep things going.
Option 3: The Management Buyout (MBO)
A management buyout means selling to the people already running the business day to day. In other words, your senior managers become the owners.
What an MBO does well
- Discretion: You don’t need to advertise the business for sale or share sensitive details with outsiders. Instead, the whole process can stay within a small circle.
- Continuity: Your managers already know the business, the clients and the processes. Little changes from the outside, which reassures staff and customers.
- Speed: Since the buyers already understand the company, they have less to learn than an outsider would.
- A reward for your team: Managers get the chance to own what they’ve helped to build.
Where an MBO falls short
- External funding: Your managers rarely have enough cash to buy the business outright. As a result, the deal typically relies on bank borrowing, the team’s own money and sometimes deferred payments from you.
- Complexity: The legal and tax positions affect both you and the incoming team, so the structure needs careful design.
- Conflicts of interest: Your managers sit on both sides of the table in a way an outside buyer doesn’t. However, clear process and proper disclosure protect everyone.
- A different price: Without competing bidders, the price depends on what the team can afford and what lenders will support.
That said, an MBO suits owners who value discretion and continuity, and who have a capable team with the means to fund a deal.
Comparing the Three at a Glance
Each route has a different centre of gravity. Here’s a simple way to think about them:
- Trade sale: best for maximising price, though it offers the least continuity.
- EOT: best for preserving culture and legacy, but payment usually arrives over time.
- MBO: best for discretion and continuity, although it relies on external funding.
No route wins on every measure. Instead, each one trades something for something else. Your job is to decide which trade-offs you’re happiest to make.
What Each Route Means for Your Team
Your staff will feel your choice more than anyone. In a trade sale, they join a bigger organisation, so roles and reporting lines may change. With an EOT, however, they become part of the ownership structure, which often builds loyalty and commitment. In a management buyout, meanwhile, a few senior people take the lead, while everyone else sees familiar leadership carry on.
Clients react in a similar way. Because a trade sale can bring change, they may worry about service. By contrast, an EOT or MBO usually keeps familiar faces in place. Therefore, early and honest communication matters whichever route you choose.
How to Decide: Three Questions to Ask Yourself
There’s no single “best” answer, because the right choice depends on your priorities. These three questions can help you find them.
1. How much do you want to maximise price versus preserve the business’s identity?
Some owners want the highest possible figure, and they accept that the business may change. Others would take a slightly lower price to protect their team and culture. Neither approach is wrong, but you need to know which one describes you.
2. How quickly do you want to exit?
A trade sale can complete relatively quickly and may deliver most of your money upfront. On the other hand, an EOT or an MBO often involves a longer handover, with payments arriving over time. Alternatively, if you’d rather step back slowly, those routes may suit you well.
3. Who do you trust to carry the business forward?
Think about the people who would own the business next. Do you trust a competitor to look after your staff? Do you believe your managers could run things well without you? Would your whole team thrive under employee ownership? Ultimately, your honest answers can point you toward the right route.
Mistakes Owners Make When Choosing
Owners who struggle with their exit often fall into the same traps:
- Assuming an outside sale is the only option: Many owners never consider the alternatives until it’s too late to use them.
- Looking at one route in isolation: Without a comparison, it’s hard to judge whether a deal is truly good.
- Focusing only on the headline price: The timing of payments, the tax position and the risk you carry all affect what you actually receive.
- Leaving it too late: Each route needs preparation, and some take months to set up properly.
- Taking advice from someone with a stake: Advisers who earn more from one route may steer you toward it.
The Bottom Line
Trade sale, employee ownership, or a buyout by your own team: three very different ways to exit. Selling to an outsider isn’t your only option, and knowing all three early gives you more control over which one you choose.
How H&Hendricks Can Help
Working out which of the three exit routes suits you and your business is one of the first conversations in H&Hendricks’ Preparing for Sale service. And because H&Hendricks is not a business broker, that advice isn’t coloured by which route is easiest for a broker to sell.
Ashley Bancroft is a founding Partner of H&Hendricks. A qualified Chartered Accountant and specialises in finance, strategy and entrepreneurship, with particular focus on value creation.
You must belogged in to post a comment.